OneBoxVision Blog

What are the key areas that impact the performance of your machine vision system?

This article puts a focus on the impact that rollers, web handling and tension will have on the performance of your machine vision system. 

Rollers, Tension variation, and the material properties of your web can have a huge adverse impact on the performance of your machine vision system. 

Rollers

Rollers are used to guide the web material along a predetermined path through a process line. Let's take a printing press as an example. The path will vary on most presses as different print jobs have varying print requirements (number of colors, cold seal, side of printing, drying time, etc.).  The web path will also vary depending on the drying times and drying temperatures of the inks. Under the inspection head, rollers are used to present the web to the cameras in as stable a condition as possible.

Below are a couple of configurations often used for a number of machine vision applications: 

Roller_1.jpgroller_2.jpg

How rollers can impact the performance of your machine vision system? 

Rollers or idlers are set in place in a precise procedure known as “tramming”. The tolerance is generally close to 0.01mm. If this “tramming” is not correct, flutter may be introduced into the system. This flutter does not necessarily have to occur at the inspection point but can in fact occur upstream. This can be the case as misalignment can stretch the material and cause bagginess on one side of the web. This is particularly true of materials that have little or no elasticity e.g. foils, whereas film is much more forgiving in this situation.

A final aspect of roller design is minimising ingress of air between the roller and the web. If a bed of air gets under the web it will cause it to aeroplane over the roller (known as “boundary layer effect”), which will result in lost encoder pulses if an encoder is used at that point. This is also known as slippage. The solution to this problem is the introduction of a “chevron” shaped groove designed to channel air away from the roller surface. A modified chevron design known as a “spreader” runs towards the edges of the roller as it rotates applying lateral forces to the web, which helps to maintain flatness of the web.

Effect of Idler Misalignment on Wrinkle Formation

A prominent problem that arise as a result of misaligned idlers is wrinkling. These wrinkles can be detected by the system as defects and as such need to be removed from the process. It is important that the defective roller be identified quickly. The following information will help you identify the cause quickly.

Understand the forces acting at a misaligned idler

There are two primary forces imparted by a misaligned idler on a web:

  • Ff - frictional force applied to the web by an idler where the idler direction and the webs direction of travel are not the same,
  • Fs - steering force is a function of the idler alignment before and after the point being considered. A misaligned idler applies a turning moment on the web, which is transferred along the press.

Measurements conducted with a single misaligned idler have shown that the effect on web tracking and thus wrinkle introduction can be seen a significant distance downstream from the misaligned idler. It is noted that the point of largest tracking variation does not occur at the idler, which is misaligned but further downstream i.e. the wrinkling gets progressively worse for a distance downstream before the steering and frictional forces balance and the web stabilises.

Tension variation

 

Principles of tension control applied to print inspection 

Print inspection systems often use a golden template algorithm. This is when a master image is compared to each printed image. These algorithms must accommodate the random web shift of the web for every repeat. Depending on the resolution of an inspection system this allowable shift may vary up to 3-4 mm per repeat. Therefore, if the fluctuations in the tension are larger, inspection can become very difficult due to the loss of alignment (matching if golden image to the printed image). However, the tension cannot be set too high either, as it will result in deformation of some materials while in other cases it will result in web breaks.

new_blog.jpg

Another effect of low or high tension is that the resulting “repeat-length” will be either too long or too short. Often stretchy or elastic substrates are printed on while stretched by excessive tension and end up with a short repeat when the substrate contracts after printing. An inspection system will see this as a gradually increasing pixel difference over the image (most pronounced at the bottom of each repeat as the run out is cumulative).

Tension control during lamination will affect golden image comparisons

As plies are laminated the resultant tension is increased to pull both plies through the press. If a third ply is laminated further along the press, the tension is further increased. This tension increase is directly linked to the total sum of the constituent plies. It is a difficult enough task to maintain one overall tension on a press, therefore maintaining up to 5 different tension zones compounds the problem.

In the laminating process it is important that the individual substrates not be of equal tension but be strained by the same % length (1% Young’s Modulus), i.e. both substrates need to be strained so that they deform by a pre-set length. This is so that during the curing process so they contract by the same amount so that no puckering of the material occurs. This is another variable to be considered during inspection if it occurs after a lamination station.

As the press is attempting to maintain constant tension during lamination, speed variations occur. It is this attempt to maintain constant tension that over large distances allows the top of a printed image presented to the camera to vary from the start of repeat signal. 

Material properties 

While it is critical to maintain constant web tension, the inherent properties of the web can act against this goal and in turn negatively impact your machine vision system. AL foil is the most stable substrates for inspection as it has low elasticity (low tension variation) and low thermal expansion (low repeat length variation). On the other hand, materials such as light gauge low-density polyethylene have high elasticity and high thermal expansion coefficients. It is in this latter case especially a number of mechanisms should be put into place to counteract problems.

There are a number of key approaches to combat the effects of material properties on the performance of your machine vision system. 

  • Chill rolls should be used to keep the web at the same temperature so that any negative effects of thermal expansion are avoided. With some poly substrates a repeat length can go from 600mm to 601mm due to thermal expansion. Such a difference in repeat length can change the relative position of each physical top of repeat from the actual start of repeat signal. This difference can result in a slow constant drift in the y-axis over time. The press heats up over a period of up to 45 minutes at the start of a print run. It is during this time the y-shift can drift in the positive direction. After the heat phase stabilises the y-shift stops.
  • PID controllers may be used to maintain even tension.
  • Well-balanced idlers (low rotational inertia) with low overall inertia mounted on low drag bearings will also help maintain constant tension. If the drag is too high it may not even be possible to pull a particular substrate through a press without exceeding its plastic deformation point.

Key terms associated with rollers, tension variation and material properties

  • Idler roller: A roller, which is driven by the web rather than by an electric motor, belt or other external means. 
  • Nip: Two parallel rolls pressed together on converting machinery between which the web passes. Used particularly to maintain tension and in lamination process to set both plies together. It is particularly difficult to maintain constant tension at this point.
  • Rewind Zone: A tension zone, typically on converting machinery, created between a driven nip roll or other tensioning point and the driven core onto which the web is wound. This zone occurs for a length preceding the rewind station. This zone can work itself back into the inspection zone and can cause problems for inspection alignment.
  • Soft start feature: A tension controller feature used in unwind zones; soft start causes the controller output to drop to a pre-set low level to prevent brake lockup when the machine starts; the feature is actuated automatically upon loss of tension below a pre-set trip point, by a change in machine speed, or by an external contact closure.
  • Taper tension feature: A means of decreasing web tension as roll diameter increases in a rewind zone; Taper tension helps produce a roll of better quality by eliminating telescoping, crushed cores, and overly tight or loose rolls.
  • Tension Zone: A length of machine in which the web is under nominally the same tension, usually between driven rollers. Ideally it is required that start of repeat signal, new line signal and imaging all occur in one tension zone.
  • Unwind Zone: A tension zone created between a driven roll or driven nip and the core from which a roll is unwound. Tension is often created by torque applied to the unwind shaft by a pneumatic brake.
  • Rotational inerties: During web acceleration or deceleration, low rotational inertia is required to minimize the web tension variation upstream and downstream of a roller. Rotational inertia results in “dynamic drag” which resists acceleration. In addition to web tension variation, excessive rotational inertia can cause the accelerating web to slip on the roller, thus loosing encoder pulses and effecting the acquisition of the 100% inspection system.

Conclusion

The OneBoxVision team has many years' experience building and installing machine vision systems. We have identified that to be successful in the web and sheet manufacturing process, understanding the transport of the product is key. To find out more about how rollers, tension variation and material properties can impact your performance and also how to avoid this negative impact download our whitepaper below. 

Download Whitepaper > 

Topics: Vision system solutions Surface inspection systems Building vision networks